Z1 Front Rotor Lockwashers - Distorting

More
04 Nov 2015 09:37 #697201 by BritGuyUSA
Replied by BritGuyUSA on topic Z1 Front Rotor Lockwashers - Distorting

jackleberry wrote: You might also consider that you may be over torquing the bolts. Locktite acts as a lubricant and if the torque spec given was intended for dry bolts (usually for brake parts, it is), then you may be over torquing by a significant amount.


Perhaps, but I don't think so. They were already collapsed/distorted by 22 ft/lbs - far under the 25-33 spec'd in the FSM. They are definitely made from a softer, more ductile material than other tab washers I've come across in other, but similar applications.

I still have a second set of these 'Koyama's for the second disc. I'll try these tonight with 'dry bolts' and dabs of grease on the mating surfaces to see if this alters the outcome.

'75 Z1-B, '78 CB750K8, .79 CBX1000, '85 VF1000R, '94 XR650L, '95 Triumph Speed Triple

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

More
04 Nov 2015 13:45 #697235 by barney
Replied by barney on topic Z1 Front Rotor Lockwashers - Distorting
You could attempt to harden them yourself with oxy/acetylene but may discolour them
The following user(s) said Thank You: BritGuyUSA

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

More
04 Nov 2015 18:40 #697296 by BritGuyUSA
Replied by BritGuyUSA on topic Z1 Front Rotor Lockwashers - Distorting
OK - so I tried again this evening using the second set of 'Koyama' tab washers supplied in the dual disc kit.

This time i used no Loctite, I greased both the contact areas on the fresh tab washers and the underside of the heads on the fresh, second set of bolts. The threads were definitely 'dry'.

Marginally better, but these were still only torqued, in steps, to the lower setting in the FSM of 25 lbs/ft. All three are distorting.


Attachment 2ndLockwashers.jpg not found



I'm done with 'Koyama' tab washers!

Tomorrow, the discs are going to be mounted using plain old flat/spring washers and Loctite.

If I change up to a trailer queen resto job down the road, then I'll hunt down new OEM tab washers when the time comes.

Thanks to all who answered this thread with tips and pointers - ultimately I think that the sub-standard nature of these 'Koyama' reproduction rotor tab washers was been shown beyond too much doubt.

'75 Z1-B, '78 CB750K8, .79 CBX1000, '85 VF1000R, '94 XR650L, '95 Triumph Speed Triple
Attachments:

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

More
05 Nov 2015 04:42 #697309 by Kidkawie
Replied by Kidkawie on topic Z1 Front Rotor Lockwashers - Distorting
I don't know how far along your build is, but you're much better off restoring/refinishing OEM parts. Aftermarket/repro stuff is hit or miss but they all have an "over restored" look IMO. I bought an aftermarket set of carb holder clamps and they seem to be made from the same cheap material as those lock washers. I just threw them out and found some decent used OEM ones.

1975 Z1 900
1994 KX250 Supermoto
2004 KX125

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

More
05 Nov 2015 06:16 #697318 by loudhvx
Replied by loudhvx on topic Z1 Front Rotor Lockwashers - Distorting
At least you can use them as twist-ties for garbage bags. :)

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

More
05 Nov 2015 06:39 #697319 by jackleberry
Replied by jackleberry on topic Z1 Front Rotor Lockwashers - Distorting
Well that sucks.

1997 KZ1000P (P16)
2001 KZ1000P (P20)

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

More
05 Nov 2015 08:03 #697333 by BritGuyUSA
Replied by BritGuyUSA on topic Z1 Front Rotor Lockwashers - Distorting

Kidkawie wrote: I don't know how far along your build is, but you're much better off restoring/refinishing OEM parts. Aftermarket/repro stuff is hit or miss but they all have an "over restored" look IMO. I bought an aftermarket set of carb holder clamps and they seem to be made from the same cheap material as those lock washers. I just threw them out and found some decent used OEM ones.


Very true. The original tab washers were MIA from a PO rebuild. Wherever possible I'm using NOS/OEM parts. Unfortunately most people who've bought out stocks of original parts and sell these on Fleabay etc., would have you believe that they are all made from 'unobtainium' and want crazy-high prices, especially if they are tagged/bagged with the original Kawa packaging and carry a Z1 part number.

For most fasteners, I order from boltdepot.com. They have a decent range of metric fasteners in the correct zinc-plated finish and you can usually get them to correct lengths, give or take a mm or so. They also sell them in 'onesies and twosies' rather than having to order 50 at a time. As long as you plan ahead, the shipping won't eat your budget up either.

'75 Z1-B, '78 CB750K8, .79 CBX1000, '85 VF1000R, '94 XR650L, '95 Triumph Speed Triple

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

More
05 Nov 2015 08:05 #697334 by BritGuyUSA
Replied by BritGuyUSA on topic Z1 Front Rotor Lockwashers - Distorting

loudhvx wrote: At least you can use them as twist-ties for garbage bags. :)


:ohmy:

:laugh:

Lesson learned.

'75 Z1-B, '78 CB750K8, .79 CBX1000, '85 VF1000R, '94 XR650L, '95 Triumph Speed Triple

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

More
05 Nov 2015 08:06 #697336 by BritGuyUSA
Replied by BritGuyUSA on topic Z1 Front Rotor Lockwashers - Distorting

jackleberry wrote: Well that sucks.


Indeed it does!

Hopefully others can learn from my experience.

'75 Z1-B, '78 CB750K8, .79 CBX1000, '85 VF1000R, '94 XR650L, '95 Triumph Speed Triple

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

More
05 Nov 2015 10:25 #697347 by Kidkawie
Replied by Kidkawie on topic Z1 Front Rotor Lockwashers - Distorting
I sent my original hardware out for replating, along with spare hardware. Nothing like waiting on some bolts to stall a project. Also, those bolts marked with 4's and 7's get pretty desirable.


1975 Z1 900
1994 KX250 Supermoto
2004 KX125

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

More
05 Nov 2015 12:12 #697359 by BritGuyUSA
Replied by BritGuyUSA on topic Z1 Front Rotor Lockwashers - Distorting

Kidkawie wrote: I sent my original hardware out for replating, along with spare hardware. Nothing like waiting on some bolts to stall a project. Also, those bolts marked with 4's and 7's get pretty desirable.


Waiting on parts can be frustrating, especially if its something small that's holding up reassembly.

I've heard lots of good things about the Caswell hobby kits for zinc plating. I may look into getting one, as the Z1 is just the first of a few of my bikes that I'm planning to rebuild in the future. I already have a good-sized ultrasonic tank plus dry- and vapor-blasting cabinets, so if I can complete the fastener/hardware refinishing process from start to finish 'in house', that should help to keep things flowing.

'75 Z1-B, '78 CB750K8, .79 CBX1000, '85 VF1000R, '94 XR650L, '95 Triumph Speed Triple

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

More
05 Nov 2015 16:41 #697385 by BritGuyUSA
Replied by BritGuyUSA on topic Z1 Front Rotor Lockwashers - Distorting
As I said - the heck with those junk repro tab washers.

I've now got both rotors snugged down tight with regular flat/spring washers, Loctite blue and 30 ft/lbs of torque.

They aren't going anywhere.

I'll keep an eye out for some OEM replacements and change them out down the road.


Attachment FrontWheela.jpg not found



Thanks again one and all.

'75 Z1-B, '78 CB750K8, .79 CBX1000, '85 VF1000R, '94 XR650L, '95 Triumph Speed Triple
Attachments:

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

Powered by Kunena Forum